Friday Roundup

Standard

Many of my blogger pals who were out of town or otherwise occupied have returned so this roundup is a bit longer than the past two.

If you haven’t checked out this month’s Commentary, have a look. There is a symposium on “Why are Jews Liberals” which makes me want to read Norman Podhoretz’ new book of the same name and a review of Michael Burleigh’s Blood & Rage: A Cultural History of Terrorism which sounds very interesting as well.

Airforce Amazons: Anti-Semitism on Shop Street

Bob from Brockley on Class Politics Versus Identity Politics

But, I am a Liberal! Realism Still A Bad Idea Pt. I

Contentious Centrist: The Essence of Evil II: Rape as

Elder of Ziyon: UNRWA defends not teaching Holocaust to PalArabs

Flesh is Grass provides a roundup on Iran

Long War Journal’s Bill Roggio on the Taliban’s killing of Afghanistan’s intelligence chief and two hijacked fuel trucks hit by a NATO airstrike

The Middle (Jewlicious): Uri Avnery Gets Lernered

Mod on Hamas

Poumista posts some Poumist Ephemera

Small Wars Journal: Major Jeremy Kotkin asks “Is the War in Afghanistan in the Interests of the U.S. and its Allies?”

Sultan Knish: The Real Root Cause of Terrorism and Is Islamic Terrorism Reactive or Proactive?

Michael Totten: Qadaffi Can Celebrate his Filthy Regime Without Us

Advertisements

3 responses »

  1. You are both welcome.

    Roland,

    Kotkin does a good job articulating a straight-forward realist analysis of the situation in this piece. As you probably gather from my posts here and comments at your blog my sympathies are more with the neoconservative and muscular liberal approach than realism.

    However, he asks some important questions, first and foremost, what ends do we seek in Afghanistan? Killing terrorists? Nation building? Some combination of the two?

    If it is the former, our military is well trained and equipped to accomplish that goal. But the latter goal, helping to create a stable state, is much more elusive and cannot be accomplished by raw military power alone. USAID, the State Department and other government agencies need to get more involved. It will also take a significant amount of money and a much more active role by our NATO partners.

    I also disagree with Kotkin re: the potential for terrorist plots to be hatched in and executed from failed states. He claims the Taliban were “in power minding their own business since 1996” but this ignores the role the role the Taliban played in developing terrorist training camps in Afghanistan and the threat that those camps represented not only to the U.S. but the entire free world.

    –TNC

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s